Should Sonya have married Dolokhov?

In Tolstoy’s famous novel War and Peace bad guy Dolokhov proposes to good girl Sonya. She refuses him, but one of the readers of this blog wondered if she should have married him after all. So let’s try to analyse this romantic affair.

Sonya

Sonya is a poor orphan cousin living with Rostovs. Tolstoy describes her as a promising kitten at the beginning of the novel. She’s very pretty, loyal, sweet and has a strong sense of justice. She’s her cousin Natasha’s best friend and this little kitten is very much in love with her cousin Nicholas.

Dolokhov

Dolokhov is a good looking officer, notorious gambler and duelist. He has no connections or money. Most people consider him a cruel and cold hearted person. In fact the only person who thinks he has a heart of gold is his mother. Dolokhov is an enigmatic character. He seems disappointed in the world and feels a strong need to revenge himself.

Sacrifice

Dolokhov tells Nicholas that he will sacrifice anything for the people he loves, but we don’t see any proof of that; au contraire, he claims to be Nicholas’ friend but not much later tries to steal his girl, and when she rejects him, he punishes Nicholas by cheating him out of 43000 (precisely 43000, because 43 is the combined age of him and Sonya) roubles in a game of cards.

Sonya really does make sacrifices: she risks her friendship with Natasha in order to prevent Natasha from eloping with Anatole. Later she writes Nicholas to forget his promise to marry her, so that he is free to marry Mary.

Does Dolokhov love Sonya?

So why does Dolokhov propose to Sonya? I’m mostly inclined to say out of jealousy. In his mind people like Pierre and Nicholas get all the good things in life because of their name, connections and money, and for the same reasons they get away with anything. Perhaps he has heard or sensed that Sonya loves Nicholas and he wants to take her from Nicholas, who, after all, already has so much good luck*.

When he is recovering from the injuries he suffered in his duel with Pierre he confides in Nicholas, telling him that he is looking for “divine purity and devotion” in women; he needs a woman who will “regenerate, purify and elevate” him. It is technically possible that he saw those qualities in Sonya, and that that’s why he proposed to her.

The refusal

Either way, Sonya was right to refuse Dolokhov. His mother may have been blind to his faults, but our Sonya is a smart girl, guided by a strong sense of right and wrong. She inadvertently uses Nicholas as an excuse, probably thinking optimistically that Dolokhov will at least be happy for his friend. Her euphoric state immediately after the refusal speaks volumes; she made the right choice.

In 19th century terms Dolokhov would have been a good match for Sonya; the old countess, who disapproves anyway of a marriage between Nicholas and Sonya, clearly thinks that Sonya should have accepted him. But Sonya is to remain single and together with the old countess she’s going to live with Nicholas and Mary. Like a cat, Tolstoy writes, she had attached herself not to the people but to the home.

And as for Dolokhov’s need to be purified, regenerated and elevated? Well, he shouldn’t rely on a woman to better his life, let alone a sweet seventeen year old girl. He shows his true colours and punishes Nicholas severely for his cousin’s love: first by making him lose a fortune and then by not preventing the death of his little brother Petya. Tolstoy doesn’t tell us if he ever found the wife of his dreams.


*In the beginning of War and Peace, Dolokhov, Pierre and Anatole tie a bear to a policeman and throw them in the river. For this ‘prank’ Dolokhov gets reduced in rank to soldier. Anatole, who is rich and well connected, remains an officer. Pierre is a civilian, but doesn’t get any punishment because of his dying (and extremely wealthy) father. Nicholas, similarly, seems to have everything going for him, he’s a count, wealthy, makes a dashing career in the army, everyone likes him, and he comes from a warm and loving family. He too is protected by his family name: For being Dolokhov’s second in the duel, he ought to have gotten punished. Instead he gets a promotion.

Have you read War and Peace? And if so, what are your feelings about Sonya and Dolokhov? Should Sonya have married Nicholas?



© Elisabeth van der Meer / illustration from War and Peace


See also:

https://arussianaffair.wordpress.com/2016/03/15/fyodor-dolokhov-the-bad-guy-from-war-and-peace/

https://arussianaffair.wordpress.com/2016/01/24/love-in-war-and-peace-1/

https://arussianaffair.wordpress.com/2016/02/07/love-in-war-and-peace-2/

Advertisements

42 thoughts on “Should Sonya have married Dolokhov?

  1. Thank you, Rebecca. It’s definitely to Tolstoy’s credit that 150 years later we are still talking about the characters he thought up as if they were real. Because as you say, we can still relate to them.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I’m glad Sonya didn’t marry Dolokov. He was much too cold to marry such a sweet girl. However, I was disappointed for her when she and Nickolai didn’t marry. But Princess Marya was a good wife for Nickolai, and they really did love each other.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I agree completely! The romance between Sonya and Nicholas started off very promising. When I first read War and Peace I thought they’d get married; Natasha would marry Andrew; and Pierre perhaps with Marya 😄 But, of course, Tolstoy made us think that on purpose 😄

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Excellent, engaging analysis, Elisabeth! Reminds me of how many “bad boy”/good woman relationships (or attempted relationships) there are in literature. Definitely makes for dramatic reading!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. That WOULD be a great blog idea, Elisabeth! I might just do it. 🙂 I could also include the opposite — relationships between admirable men and not-so-admirable women.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. In Russian literature of XVIII-XIX there are a lot of the same situations when the beautiful but not reach girls had a marriage proposal from men who either rich or had a scandalous popularity. They rejected because all these proposals were not sincere although girl’s mothers really wanted these marriages. Pretty often these stories had the tragic end. It looks by that time it was pretty common situation. It is difficult to say were these girls right or wrong. We cannot make the decision for them. It is what it is. I think they made the right choice.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Very insightful, thank you, Luanne. I think so too, she could not have saved him, and he would have brought her down with him. She was so good and pure, and he was the opposite, she would have been ashamed of/for him and bis past.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. So, I saw your great article yesterday morning, but I had no idea what my opinion in this case is… …because, psst, don’t tell: I only watched the movie when I was a kid and never read the book. BUT, you know, a guy with my background should better have an opinion about that and I saw it as a kind of duty to tell you what I thing about her best decision. …hours later there was still this blank comment box on my screen… …so I decided to consult an real expert in that topic. Victoria!

    After a twenty minutes long dialogue I was in need to interrupt her, because it was a kind of overflow of information for my brain… “..it depends on… …the historical background of this time… …the special ideology of the family… …different time windows and doors that opened up and closed for Sonya during the plot.. …even Tolstois changing world view is to consider…. …do you mean it under consideration of nowadays ideology?… …the best would be if Sonya would marry…” You see, it’s not that easy… …even if you consult an expert.

    Sonya, my advice… …follow your heart… …grab that guy you love! Go wherever you want! …because the steps in life that you climb which are encouraged by love, are always right and will be rewarded. 🙂

    wish you a nice day
    smiles, Markus

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Haha, yes, of course Victoria is right. It all depends on the circumstances and when we read War and Peace now, we tend to see it in the light of our contemporary ideas about marriage. I’m sure Tolstoy wouldn’t mind, it’s his own fault for writing such a timeless classic!
    Have a happy weekend,
    Elisabeth

    Like

  10. ppff.. ..true… …why he did such things. 😀
    ..but I think there is in deed an impact by literature of that time towards the nowadays marriage behavior. We know a few couples who marry after two weeks from their first date. A few in-between the first three month. …and I think it comes from that heroic and romantic ideas conveyed by the novels of that days. …and you see… …his fault again. 😦 ..oh boy.. …Leo, what have you done to us. 😀 😉

    have a wonderful easter weekend!!
    Markus

    Liked by 1 person

  11. That is very quick! 😄 First impressions can be deceptive. Let’s hope the marriages make it anyway. Otherwise they’ll start fighting duels as well 😄

    You have a wonderful Easter weekend too! 🌷🐣🐰🥚

    Like

  12. …Victoria’s friends where shocked, that I didn’t made a proposal within the first year. 😀 ..but who cares. At least we brought it to 18 years… …and many lucky years will follow.. …without duels. 😀 😉

    A wonderful easter holiday for you too 🐣🐰🥚🌷

    Liked by 1 person

  13. It’s the kind of book that offers something to everyone, and it’s a good read. For me the main attraction is that you feel that you really get to know the different characters and empathise with them.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s